top of page

Why Your Best Employees Stay: A Business Owner’s Guide to Stay Interviews

Nov 9
3 min read

When a valued employee resigns, one of your first questions is probably, “What could we have done differently?”


An exit interview might give you some answers. But by that point, the employee has made their decision, and you’re planning a handover and recruitment.

Stay interviews give you a chance to have that conversation earlier.

For business owners and leaders, they’re a practical way to understand what employees value, what’s getting in their way, and where you may need to make changes.

What is a stay interview?


A stay interview is a focused conversation about an employee’s experience working for your business.


You’re asking what makes them want to stay, what could make them consider leaving, and what would make their work more satisfying.


Keep it separate from performance reviews so there’s enough time to focus on their experience. If you’re discussing performance targets, compensation decisions, and employee feedback all at once, the conversation can become crowded quickly.


You can keep the process simple. Book a dedicated conversation, explain the purpose ahead of time, and prepare a few thoughtful questions.


What should you ask?

Use open-ended questions that give employees room to explain their answers.

Good starting points include:

  • What do you enjoy most about working here?

  • What makes a good workday for you?

  • What regularly gets in the way of doing your job well?

  • Do you have opportunities to learn and develop?

  • What could I do differently to support you?

  • What might make you consider another opportunity?


You don’t need to work through a long questionnaire. A few useful questions, with time to explore the answers, can give you plenty to work with.


Ask follow-up questions such as, “Can you give me an example?” or “What would an improvement look like?”


Make it easier to be honest


Your response will shape how comfortable employees feel sharing feedback.

If someone raises a concern and you immediately explain why they’re wrong, they may decide to keep the next concern to themselves.


Listen first. Ask questions to understand their experience. Thank them for being direct.

You can acknowledge feedback without agreeing to every request. You might say:

“Thanks for explaining that. I can see why the changing priorities have been frustrating. Let me look at how we’re assigning work and come back to you next week.”


Be clear about how you’ll use the information and who may need to be involved. Avoid promising confidentiality you can’t maintain.


Decide what you can act on

Some feedback may lead to a straightforward change, such as a clearer handover process or more regular manager check-ins.


Other requests may involve budget, staffing, or decisions you can’t make immediately.

Be honest about those limits. If you can’t approve a request, explain what you considered and whether there’s another option.


Look for themes across conversations too. If several employees describe unclear priorities, that gives you a specific leadership issue to investigate.


You don’t need to solve everything at once. Choose a manageable number of actions and give each one an owner and a timeline.


Close the loop

Before you finish the conversation, summarize what you heard and agree on the next step.

Then follow up when you said you would, even if the update is that you need more time.

At your next check-in, ask whether the change has helped. A new process may look good on paper while creating a different challenge for the people using it.


Stay interviews can’t guarantee that an employee will stay. They can give you a clearer understanding of your team and a chance to address concerns earlier.

Want help introducing stay interviews in your business? VIMY HR can help you build a practical process and turn employee feedback into clear next steps.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page